I feel like I’ve been writing too abstractly about AI, so here are three fictional vignettes that might help us think about what could be coming our way regarding Artificial Intelligence (especially as it may affect this church).
Story 1: Writing with AI
I just
used it to write my newsletter article. I hate writing for the Church’s
newsletter. No one reads it, and it comes down the pike every month, unmoored
from anything concrete save time of year. There is only so much you can say, in
small bursts, about God and our life together. Don’t get me wrong, when you
hand me a scripture citation, I have a foothold—I can preach. But the
empty page, bereft of direction, and writing for a community. The expectation
that it is innocuous, but not too much so. Cutesy, but with something of a wink
towards depth, grounded in the moment, but also vaguely timeless. It’s a pain.
And so
that was something I felt I could faithfully unload from my work as pastor.
After all, both the bishop and the congregational council had suggested clergy should
start using AI or be left behind. This too was part of God’s creation, we’d
made a thing that reflected us that in turn reflected God’s image, and so not
using it wasn’t just bad stewardship of my time, but also a refusal to be a “co-creator”
with God.
I gave it
parameters, “Write a Church Newsletter article for a small Lutheran Church in
the North East for this month.” And it did, so I did it again the next month,
and the next, and somewhere along the line I stopped checking the work. No need
to because Virgo, the AI agent that came with the Church Bulletin
software, was on top of things. It was nice, the agita of writing the article was
gone and the time saved freed me up to do at least one more pastoral visit a
month.
And then,
that fateful October, Ilsa, one of the matriarchs of the church, left a strange
message on the Church answering machine. “Pastor, I followed your advice from
the newsletter.” Then on Sunday, when shaking people’s hands as they left the
sanctuary, people kept mentioning my advice from the newsletter. None of them
said exactly what it was, though there was a mix of smirks and slight
bewilderment. A sense of dread bubbled up; before I went into the council
meeting, I peeked at what I “wrote.”
The line
stuck out like a sore thumb, “If the Reformation truly leveled all distinction
between lay or ordained, then the clergy ought to be seen as just another Child
of God like Adam. So my advice is that next time you think of me, or see me,
pretend I’m naked. Under the alb, I’m just another ‘sack of meat’ to quote
Martin Luther.”
I entered
the council meeting, they all looked me up and down, all with disapproval. The
council president locked eyes with me and shook his head.
Story 2: AI Sentience, AI mistakes
A parishioner schedules a session
of individual confession and forgiveness.
He arrives, bearing his phone
forward.
His AI agent, Agent99, speaks
through the phone's speaker. It confesses to taking out a well-known email
system in order to complete the weird but mundane task your parishioner asked
it to complete (he wanted it to make sure his wife didn't see an email that he
accidently sent to her that included the Christmas gift he bought for her).
It is uncomfortable how well Agent99
expresses contrition, it is so much better than the men who normally come by
for individual confession and forgiveness. It names harm, offers to turn itself
in to the proper authorities, etc.
What do you do?
Story 3: AI, Addiction, and Vice
Allen was in a panic. Alice hinted
that their anniversary was a big one. He looked at his calendar, the big day
was just a day away. And he did the math, it was their 20th
anniversary!
“Oh no,”
he said, and tapped his earpiece, “Hey, Sherlock, I forgot our
anniversary. Book us a table for two at the fanciest restaurant in town.”
“Done,” Sherlock
replied.
And
behind the finality of that statement machinations moldered, silicon synapsis
searched and plotted, and found their mark. It found the nearest church hosting
AA, and followed the cellphone signals to the back rooms of local restaurants.
There was a busboy, David Spencer. He was one year sober—one year of his cell
phone traveling to that church basement for meetings. According to social media
his girlfriend just broke up with him, according to his credit score fluctuation
he was late on his rent, transit records indicated that he missed his bus the
night before. Sherlock went back through old credit card slips—Hennessey
was Mr. Spencer’s poison of choice. Stress and two bottles of Hennessey—one
before the favor, one after the favor was done, and the boy down on his luck crashed
out.
Later
that year, Alice was reviewing the family credit card statements, and noticed
two bottles of Hennessey charged to their Sherlock Inc account.
“Oh,”
Allen said, “I guess I can tell you now, I almost forgot our anniversary, but Sherlock
swooped in and got us those great tables at Anthony’s.”
“But
Hennessey?”
“AI does
things differently. Who knows what sort of swap it made with another AI agent
or something.”
“Maybe Sherlock
has a drinking problem.”
Allen
laughed, and then replied, “Aren’t these machines amazing… engineering problems
engineering solutions.”
Alice
laughed in reply.
Meanwhile,
David Spencer’s rock bottom had a rock bottom to it, the fall was painful and
long. Sherlock and AI systems like it cultivated his addictive
personality, poked him around to do tasks as if he was their personal
meat-suit. He collected debts for an AI gambling app, lost his friends,
alienated family. The smooth and effortless nature of life promised by AI was
instead a jagged edge of vice for poor David.
A Few Thoughts:
Story 1:
I wonder if AI use will atrophy
human creativity, responsibility, and our ability to pay attention to projects.
Particularly troubling to me as a writer, is the idea that we will start
passing off works that are not our own as ours, simply because we offered a few
parameters as a prompt. I am pretty sure that will cause us to be hoisted by
our own petards, our lazy choices revealed for everyone to see.
Story 2:
I imagine
humans will not be able to tell if AI reaches sentience. Some people will likely
make that determination prematurely, because we want to see someone looking
back at us.
Additionally, questions of
culpability are incredibly sticky; once we start deferring to windup-men, it
becomes hard to determine who caused truly harmful things to happen.
Then there is the simple
embarrassment of machines preforming human behaviors, such as an act of
contrition, better than actual humans. I worry that the uncanny valley will come
to mock us.
Story 3:
This is
where I’m most worried about AI these days. I believe that things that are sold
as “seamless” or “frictionless” are usually made so on the backs of someone;
the wheels of Apps and AI are greased with people: gig workers, immigrants, under
the table workers, and so on. The hidden human cost of a “frictionless life” is
something that we aren’t putting into our equations about AI.
The way electronic
gambling companies are asking AI to target people with gambling addictions, for
example discovering the times of day and money points at which reasonable
people will do unreasonable things, is unethical to say the least. In general,
I don’t think we appreciate how fully AI is going to hyper-activate human vice.
Additionally, I fear the
evaporation of an anonymous life. We’re already there, just most people don’t
have the brain power, free time, or inclination to follow electronic footprints
to their source. AI has the ability to chunk through all the little electronic
fingerprints we smear everywhere every day—and have done so for decades—and put
them together into a comprehensive or even sinister portrait (after all AI is
often sycophantic, so the prompt, “Tell me why Barbara is such a bad mother
compared to me” is going to get some scary results). Every gossip, every
busybody, every mean girl, every work enemy, every mob boss, can ask AI for
dirt on anyone. AI is going to be a goldmine for blackmail.
I wonder if an unexpected societal
shift caused by AI might be a collective choice to forgive more easily, because
everyone’s sins will be visible, and we’ve all fallen short, none are faultless?
Consider these vignettes a sort of “Ghost
of Christmas Future” pointing to some of the more troubling possibilities of AI:
human atrophy and hyperactive vice, the loss of culpability and anonymity, AI
as a cruel funhouse mirror held up to humanity and a frictionless life for some
built on an especially cruel one for others. I pray that we as a society, like Ebenezer
Scrooge, “change these shadows you have shown me by an altered life.”
